Doron Zeilberger's Response to Lara Pudwell's Referee Report on
"On Vince Vatter's Brilliant Extension of Doron Zeilberger's
Enumeration Schemes for Herb Wilf Classes"
Written: March 26, 2007.
I agree with all the corrections suggested in
Lara Pudwell's Report,
and made them in this revised version,
except the second one and the fifth.
Regarding the second one (in this revised version
it is at the top of p.3), these are not random Greek letters but
the real numbers Pi, Euler's constant gamma, e (the base
of the natural logartithms), and phi, the Golden Ratio.
Regarding the fifth comment, I believe that it is right the
way it is stated.
back to the
article.